Head-to-head
OrderlyMeds vs Care Bare Rx
Compared on both medications across the eight dimensions this database records. They differ on 5 of those eight. Care Bare Rx is cheaper on all-in tirzepatide at 10 mg/week, though on a flat-versus-tiered matchup the cheaper program can change further up the dose ladder.
The short answer
OrderlyMeds is $299 a month all-in for tirzepatide; Care Bare Rx is $199. Over twelve months that is $3,588 against $2,388. Value Scores are 67.3 and 84.9 out of 100.
Tirzepatide
Plan pages: OrderlyMeds plans · Care Bare Rx plans
At 10 mg/week, OrderlyMeds is $299 a month all-in and Care Bare Rx is $199 — $100 apart, or $1,200 across a year. Over twelve months the totals are $3,588 (billed monthly) and $2,388 (billed monthly).
OrderlyMeds charges a flat $299 per month for tirzepatide at every dose from 2.5 to 15 mg per week, so titrating upward does not change what you pay.
Care Bare Rx charges a flat $199 per month for tirzepatide at every dose from 2.5 to 15 mg per week, so titrating upward does not change what you pay.
| Dose | OrderlyMeds | Rank | Care Bare Rx | Rank | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.5 mg | $299 | 19/31 | $199 | 6/31 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| 5 mg | $299 | 9/17 | $199 | 4/17 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| 7.5 mg | $299 | 9/17 | $199 | 4/17 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| 10 mg | $299 | 13/27 | $199 | 4/27 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| 12.5 mg | $299 | 9/17 | $199 | 4/17 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| 15 mg | $299 | 9/17 | $199 | 4/17 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
Care Bare Rx is cheaper at every dose where both publish a price, so the lead does not change as you titrate.
Across the 27 programs this database can rank on tirzepatide, OrderlyMeds sits 11 of 27 on all-in monthly cost and Care Bare Rx sits 4. There are 6 other programs priced between them. The field median is $339 and the floor is $169, so both sit below the median. OrderlyMeds is $130 above the cheapest tirzepatide program on record. Care Bare Rx is $30 above the cheapest tirzepatide program on record.
LillyDirect (Zepbound), the lowest FDA-approved tirzepatide channel here, is $449 a month — OrderlyMeds undercuts it by $150, Care Bare Rx by $250. Compounded products are not FDA approved; insurance can reverse that comparison.
| Plan term | OrderlyMeds | Care Bare Rx | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month to month | $299 | $199 | Care Bare Rx by $100 |
| Settled dose | OrderlyMeds | Care Bare Rx | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.5 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
| 5 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
| 7.5 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
| 10 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
| 12.5 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
| 15 mg | $3,588 | $2,388 | $1,200 apart |
OrderlyMeds publishes no rate for 3-month term, 6-month term, 12-month term; Care Bare Rx publishes none for 3-month term, 6-month term, 12-month term. An unpublished term is not necessarily unavailable — it is unpriced in public, which you can only resolve by asking.
A titration year is not twelve months at the maintenance price. Stepping up roughly four weeks per dose before settling at 10 mg/week, the first twelve months work out to $3,588 on OrderlyMeds and $2,388 on Care Bare Rx. Both programs charge one flat rate, so the ramp costs the same as any other stretch of the year.
Value Scores are 67.3 for OrderlyMeds and 84.9 for Care Bare Rx, against a tirzepatide category floor of $169. Care Bare Rx leads by 17.6 points, driven mostly by price.
| Program | Price /70 | Evidence /15 | Dose /10 | Membership /5 | Total /100 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OrderlyMeds | 39.6 | 12.8 | 10 | 5 | 67.3 |
| Care Bare Rx | 59.5 | 10.5 | 10 | 5 | 84.9 |
Semaglutide
Plan pages: OrderlyMeds plans · Care Bare Rx plans
At 2.4 mg/week, OrderlyMeds is $149 a month all-in and Care Bare Rx is $199 — $50 apart, or $600 across a year. Over twelve months the totals are $1,788 (billed monthly) and $2,388 (billed monthly).
OrderlyMeds charges a flat $149 per month for semaglutide at every dose from 0.25 to 2.4 mg per week, so titrating upward does not change what you pay.
Care Bare Rx charges a flat $199 per month for semaglutide at every dose from 0.25 to 2.4 mg per week, so titrating upward does not change what you pay.
OrderlyMeds is cheaper at every dose where both publish a price, so the lead does not change as you titrate.
Value Scores are 88.4 for OrderlyMeds and 70.9 for Care Bare Rx, against a semaglutide category floor of $129. OrderlyMeds leads by 17.5 points, driven mostly by price.
Where the two programs differ
All-in monthly
Care Bare Rx is cheaper month to month — $199 against $299, a gap of $100 every month, or $1,200 across a year if both rates hold.
Cancellation terms
Cancellation differs: OrderlyMeds states Cancel before renewal, while Care Bare Rx states Per provider terms. Read this next to the twelve-month figures — a prepaid discount and a restrictive refund policy are the same decision.
Commitment
OrderlyMeds asks for Month-to-month available; Care Bare Rx asks for Monthly (confirm at enrollment). This is the dimension most likely to change which program is actually cheaper for you, because the lowest rates on both sides are usually attached to the longest terms.
Evidence status
The two prices are not equally well evidenced. OrderlyMeds's figure is provider-stated and Care Bare Rx's is reported. OrderlyMeds rests on the stronger of the two, and the Value Score below reflects that — evidence quality is worth fifteen points and is not a tiebreaker we apply after the fact.
Twelve-month cost
Over twelve months the totals are $3,588 for OrderlyMeds and $2,388 for Care Bare Rx. Care Bare Rx is lower by $1,200 — a figure worth checking against the cancellation terms below, because a prepaid year is only cheaper if you stay on it.
Dose policy
Both hold one price across the whole dose ladder, so neither punishes titration and the monthly figures above are what you actually pay at 15 mg as well as at 2.5 mg.
Membership fee
Neither charges a separate membership fee.
Shipping
Shipping is handled the same way by both — included in the quoted price.
What each record says
OrderlyMeds Official site
OrderlyMeds runs an all-inclusive model — $149/month compounded semaglutide and $299/month compounded tirzepatide with no membership fee — placing it near the front of the no-membership pack on semaglutide.
It does not publicly name its compounding pharmacy; the record shows Partner compounding pharmacies, so who actually makes the medication cannot be independently verified; commitment terms are Month-to-month available; cancellation is Cancel before renewal; availability is stated as Most US states.
Evidence: provider-stated — taken from the provider's own published pages; checkout capture pending, captured . Source — orderlymeds.com pricing capture 2026-08-05
Watch: Tirzepatide figure is provider-stated from published pages; checkout capture pending.
Care Bare Rx Official site
Care Bare Rx is a cash-pay compounded GLP-1 telehealth service offering both semaglutide and tirzepatide from $199/mo. It operates a lighter clinical model — confirm prescriber availability and refill cadence before enrolling.
It does not publicly name its compounding pharmacy; the record shows Partner 503A pharmacy (not named publicly), so who actually makes the medication cannot be independently verified; commitment terms are Monthly (confirm at enrollment); cancellation is Per provider terms; availability is stated as Confirm at intake.
Evidence: reported — sourced from dated third-party reporting; first-party capture pending, captured . Source — rangeyourself.com, 2026 capture
Watch: Lighter clinical model; confirm prescriber availability, refill cadence and pharmacy identity before enrolling. Reported status from RangeYourself 2026 data.
What neither record tells you
OrderlyMeds does not publish
- no published twelve-month tirzepatide rate
- no published twelve-month semaglutide rate
- no named compounding pharmacy
- no state-by-state availability list — it says Most US states
Care Bare Rx does not publish
- no published twelve-month tirzepatide rate
- no published twelve-month semaglutide rate
- no named compounding pharmacy
- no state-by-state availability list — it says Confirm at intake
- no specific cancellation or refund terms
Ask OrderlyMeds and Care Bare Rx for each of those in writing before enrolling. A gap is not evidence of a problem; it does mean nothing can be checked against it.
What would change this answer
Evidence may be upgraded. Care Bare Rx carries a price we have not captured at checkout. A capture would move the evidence term and could reorder these two without any price changing.
Which one suits which reader
On the lowest standing monthly rate for tirzepatide, Care Bare Rx Official site wins this matchup. And if you would rather trust a better-evidenced number, orderlymeds's price rests on stronger provenance.
Both figures should be checked at the provider's own checkout before you pay. OrderlyMeds's tirzepatide price is provider-stated as of 2026-08-05; Care Bare Rx's is reported as of 2026-07-14.
Questions
Is OrderlyMeds or Care Bare Rx cheaper for tirzepatide?
Care Bare Rx is cheaper on all-in monthly cost at 10 mg/week: $199 against $299, a difference of $100 a month. All-in means the medication plus every mandatory recurring fee.
What is the twelve-month cost of OrderlyMeds versus Care Bare Rx?
OrderlyMeds works out to $3,588 across twelve months and Care Bare Rx to $2,388, on the plan terms each publishes.
Does OrderlyMeds or Care Bare Rx raise the price as the dose goes up?
OrderlyMeds: no, it charges one flat rate at every dose. Care Bare Rx: no, it charges one flat rate at every dose. Where one program is flat and the other is tiered, the cheaper of the two can change as you titrate upward.
How many ways do OrderlyMeds and Care Bare Rx differ?
5 of the eight dimensions this site records: all-in monthly, twelve-month cost, dose policy, membership, shipping, commitment, cancellation terms and evidence status.
Which of OrderlyMeds and Care Bare Rx names its pharmacy?
Neither. OrderlyMeds records Partner compounding pharmacies and Care Bare Rx records Partner 503A pharmacy (not named publicly). Without a named pharmacy, neither program's licensing or inspection history can be checked before you order.
How well evidenced are the OrderlyMeds and Care Bare Rx prices?
OrderlyMeds's tirzepatide figure is provider-stated — taken from the provider's own published pages; checkout capture pending — captured 2026-08-05. Care Bare Rx's is reported, captured 2026-07-14. Evidence status is worth fifteen points in the Value Score, so it is priced in rather than mentioned as an aside.
Which is cheaper for semaglutide?
OrderlyMeds, at $149 a month all-in against $199 at 2.4 mg/week. The two programs do not necessarily lead on both medications.
Official sources: OrderlyMeds official site · Care Bare Rx official site. Compounded tirzepatide and semaglutide are not FDA-approved products.